Homeowner Guide • Flat Roofing
Can You Put a New Flat Roof Over Old Felt?
By Elite Paving & Roofing Ltd, run by director Jerry Connors
In certain situations, yes—you can overlay an existing flat roof with a new layer of felt or rubber. On a dry, solid concrete garage roof, it can save time and skip costs. On a residential extension where water has already got underneath the old covering, laying a new roof over the top usually just seals in dampness and hides rotting timber decking.
Local Know-How for Canterbury & Kent
- If you repair or re-cover an existing pitched or flat roof, you will not normally need a building control application if less than 25 per cent of the total building envelope (walls, floor, roof, windows, doors, roof windows and rooflights) is affected and less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected. Approval is still needed if you exceed either limit, make structural alterations, use a covering with significantly different fire performance, or increase the covering weight by 15 per cent or more. Source: Planning Portal, Canterbury City Council.
- Canterbury City Council says the district has 97 conservation areas. In a conservation area some external works that would not normally need permission do need it, and Article 4 directions can remove permitted development rights. Source: Canterbury City Council.
Related: Flat roofing · Our work in Canterbury
The Short Answer From the Tools
Overlaying only makes sense when the existing felt is still firmly stuck down, the timber or concrete deck underneath is completely dry and solid, and the roof already drains properly. The moment you feel a soft spot underfoot, see pooling water, or spot bubbling blisters, stripping the old roof back to the joists is the only job worth paying for.
When Overlaying Works vs. When It Is a False Economy
A lot of homeowners ask about overlaying because they want to avoid the mess and cost of stripping off old bitumen and hiring a skip. Sometimes that is a sensible call. Other times, a roofer offering a cheap overlay is just giving you a five-year headache while the decking rots out of sight.
When an Overlay Can Work
- Detached, unheated garages or sheds: Buildings without living space underneath have far lower condensation risks and usually do not trigger insulation upgrade rules.
- Concrete roof decks: Concrete will not rot like timber, so as long as it is dry and properly primed, overlaying can be straightforward.
- Early UV wear only: The mineral chippings are wearing thin or crazing on top, but there have been no leaks and the underlying felt is still tight and flat.
- Good existing falls: Rainwater already runs cleanly to the gutter without sitting in deep puddles.
When You Must Strip Back
- Spongy or bouncy spots: A clear sign that old chipboard, ply, or OSB decking has got wet and started to break down.
- Trapped blisters or ripples: Bubbles in old felt mean moisture or air is already trapped beneath the surface.
- Active leaks or damp ceilings: Once water is inside the roof build-up, sealing over the top traps it there.
- Multiple old layers: Some older Canterbury properties already have two or three layers of tar and felt piled up, adding dead weight and failing along the perimeter edges.
- GRP fibreglass systems: Fibreglass resin cannot be laid onto old bitumen felt; it always needs a fresh, dry timber deck.
The Real Risk: Trapped Condensation & Rotting Decking
Water rarely enters a flat roof right in the middle of a flat sheet. Nine times out of ten, it creeps in at a split corner, around a skylight, or behind tired lead flashing against the house wall. From there, it tracks sideways across the timber boards—especially older chipboard decking, which swells up like cardboard as soon as it gets damp.
If you torch a fresh cap sheet or glue an EPDM membrane straight over damp boards, that water is locked in. When the summer sun heats the black surface, trapped moisture turns into vapour and pushes up into large blisters, pulling the new welds apart. Over the colder months, damp timber has no way to breathe, accelerating wet rot in the boards and eventually into the ceiling joists below.
Warm-to-cold air movement inside a house causes similar trouble. Without a proper vapour control layer on the warm side of the roof, steam from a kitchen or bathroom rises through the plasterboard and condenses on the underside of the cold decking. Stripping back gives you the chance to fit a vapour barrier and rigid insulation properly so the timber stays warm and dry all year.
Building Regulations: the 25% and 50% Limits
The Planning Portal's rule for work to an existing pitched or flat roof is that you will not normally need a building control application if less than 25 per cent of the total building envelope (walls, floor, roof, windows, doors, roof windows and rooflights) is affected and less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected. You will need approval if you exceed either limit, make structural alterations, use a new covering that would perform significantly differently in a fire, or use a covering that increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more. Going over either limit can also mean the roof insulation has to be brought up to current standards.
You can check the exact thresholds in the Planning Portal guidance on work to an existing roof. If your contractor is not registered under a self-certification scheme, you or your roofer will need to notify the council through the Canterbury building control application portal before starting work.
Practical detail to check on site: Upgrading to a modern warm roof means adding rigid PIR insulation boards (often 120mm to 150mm thick) on top of the deck. Before agreeing to that, check the height beneath your upstairs window sills and patio door thresholds—you still need enough upstand height (ideally 150mm) so driving rain cannot splash over the flashing.
What Actually Drives the Cost Difference?
On paper, an overlay looks cheaper because you skip the labour of tearing off old felt. In practice, if a roof is past its best, the extra cost of doing a full strip and re-deck is usually far smaller than the cost of paying twice within a few years. Here is what makes up the price on a typical flat roof job:
- Waste removal and skip hire: Old multi-layer bitumen felt, gravel chippings, and sodden boards are heavy and need proper disposal.
- Decking and firring strips: Replacing rotten boards with 18mm OSB3 tongue-and-groove or exterior-grade plywood, and fitting tapered firring strips so rainwater actually drains rather than sitting in puddles.
- Insulation boards: Adding foil-faced PIR insulation to bring a heated extension up to current thermal standards.
- Choice of covering: Three-layer torch-on felt, single-ply EPDM rubber, or GRP fibreglass all vary slightly in material cost and detailing time around pipes and corners.
- Perimeter trims and leadwork: Replacing split lead wall flashings, installing new drip trims into the gutter, and renewing rotted fascia boards along the eaves.
If you want a clearer picture of how different systems compare on durability and finish, you can read more about our flat roofing installations and re-roofing systems across Canterbury and the surrounding villages.
What Happens on the Day When We Check or Replace a Flat Roof
We never quote a blind overlay from the pavement. On inspection, we get up on the roof, walk the deck to check for deflection, inspect the gutter line and wall flashings, and—if there is any doubt—lift a small edge or cut a neat test core that gets sealed straight back up.
Step 1: Strip & Inspect
If a full replacement is needed, we strip the old felt and damaged boards early in the morning when the forecast is clear, inspecting every joist for wet rot before anything goes back down.
Step 2: Deck, Falls & Warmth
We fix new firring pieces if needed for drainage, lay solid 18mm decking, install the vapour control layer and insulation boards, and make the roof watertight before nightfall.
Step 3: Flashings & Clean-Up
Lead flashings are chased neatly into brickwork and pointed, new edge trims direct water cleanly into the gutter, and all old felt, nails, and offcuts are cleared off your drive and garden.
Four Things to Ask Before Accepting an Overlay Quote
- Have you checked the boards underneath? Any roofer recommending an overlay should have walked the roof and checked the timber edges along the fascia.
- Will water still pond after the job is done? A new layer of felt follows the shape of the old roof—if puddles sit there now, they will sit on the new roof too.
- Are you replacing the lead flashing or just painting over it? Smeared bituminous paint over cracked lead rarely lasts more than a winter or two.
- Does this room need Building Control sign-off? Make sure you get a straight answer on whether insulation upgrades apply to your extension.
Want an Honest Look at Your Flat Roof?
We will get up on the roof, check the decking and flashings properly, and give you a straight written quote—whether that means a simple repair, a sound overlay on a garage, or a full strip and re-deck.
Related Services & Guides
← Back to All GuidesFlat Roofing Canterbury
Elite Paving and Roofing LTD offers expert flat roofing installations and repairs in Canterbury & Kent. Trust our durable GRP, EPDM and felt systems. Free quote today!
Do I Need Planning Permission for a Driveway?
Check if a new driveway in Canterbury or Kent needs planning permission: the five-square-metre rule, permeable surfaces and KCC dropped kerbs.
How Much Does a New Patio Cost?
Get realistic per-square-metre patio costs. Learn how excavation, sub-base depth, drainage and waste removal drive prices so you can compare quotes.
How Long Does Garden Landscaping Take?
Realistic timescales for garden landscaping in Kent, and how access, clay soil, wet weather and a KCC skip licence affect the start date.
Do You Need Scaffolding for Roof Work?
Find out when roof work requires scaffolding rather than ladders, how long it stays up, and when you need a Kent pavement licence.
Block Paving Patterns: Which Is Strongest?
Compare herringbone, stretcher bond and basket weave for driveways in Canterbury and Kent, and how edges and a compacted base stop wheel rutting.
Resin-Bound vs Resin-Bonded: What's Different?
Compare permeable resin-bound and non-porous resin-bonded driveways, and what the front-garden five-square-metre drainage rule means in Kent.
How Long Does a Tarmac Driveway Last?
How long a tarmac driveway lasts, what makes edges crumble, and when a front-garden tarmac drive in Kent needs planning permission.
What Is the Best Gravel Size for a Driveway?
Whether 14mm or 20mm angular shingle is best for a driveway, plus depth, membranes, grids, and why gravel can be permitted development.
Is Porcelain Paving Slippery When Wet?
Why outdoor R11 porcelain keeps its grip in the rain, unlike indoor tiles, and how a full mortar bed keeps slabs secure.
Should You Seal an Indian Sandstone Patio?
Whether to seal an Indian sandstone patio against lichen, stains and frost, when to wait after laying, and matte versus colour-enhancing sealers.
Why Do Patio Slabs Come Loose?
Why patio slabs rock or sink (spot-bedding, frost heave and failed pointing), and how re-bedding and repointing fix it.
Does Artificial Grass Drain Properly in Rain?
Learn how perforated backing, granite dust, and a Type 1 sub-base drain heavy rain on Kent clay, plus how to keep pet lawns puddle- and odour-free.
Wooden vs Concrete Fence Posts: Which Lasts?
Timber versus concrete fence posts for rot and wind, and the Planning Portal 1-metre / 2-metre height rules for fences in England.
Signs Your Chimney Needs Repointing or Flashing
Signs of chimney trouble (lifted lead, cracked flaunching, loft damp), and when chimney work in a Canterbury conservation area needs permission.
Can Pressure Washing Damage Paving or Stone?
How high-pressure jet washing can pit sandstone and strip pointing, and safer rotary cleaning and re-sanding methods.
How Soon Can You Walk on and Mow New Turf?
How soon you can walk on and mow new turf, how to check it has rooted, and watering and first-cut tips.
Can You Fix a Leaking Roof From Inside the Loft?
Why internal sealants and spray foam can trap moisture in a loft, and when a roof repair in Kent needs Building Regulations approval.
Why Is Rainwater Dripping Behind My Gutters?
Why rainwater drips behind apparently clear gutters (perished eaves felt, missing trays and sagging brackets), and how to put it right.
Do Gutter Guards and Hedgehogs Actually Work?
Whether mesh gutter guards and brush hedgehogs actually help with leaves, moss and roof grit, and when hand clearing is better.